Evaluation Methods of Frailty in the Community-dwelling Elderly

doi:10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2021.00.012

Abstract

Abstract: Frailty is a common clinical syndrome in the elderly. General practitioners，the gatekeepers for people's health，play an important role in the identification of frailty in the elderly. A large number of evaluation methods of frailty have been developed in foreign countries，but the research in this field is still in the early stage in China. To provide help for domestic general practitioners to evaluate frailty in elderly people and conduct related studies，we reviewed the evaluation methods of frailty with a concise description of their contents，strengths and limitations，as well as the application of their Chinese versions in evaluating frailty in community-dwelling Chinese older adults，and summarized the key points as follows：these methods may be classified into frailty screening methods and comprehensive evaluation methods. The Fried Frailty Phenotype，Tilburg Frailty Indicator，Groningen Frailty Indicator，the Frail Scale，Comprehensive Frailty Assessment Instrument，walking speed，grip strength and Timed Up-and-Go test are suggested to be used as screening methods of frailty in community outpatients，and Edmonton Frailty Scale and Frailty Index can be used for comprehensive evaluation. The applicability and effectiveness of the evaluation methods in different populations need to be verified in further research.

Key words: Community, Aged, Frailty, Evaluation, Review

摘要： 衰弱是老年人常见的临床综合征。全科医生作为民众健康的守门人，在社区老年人衰弱的识别中发挥着重要作用。目前国际上开发了多种衰弱评估方法，但我国在此方面的研究仍处于起步阶段。本文就衰弱评估方法的内容、优缺点，以及在我国社区老年人中调适、应用情况进行综述，旨在为全科医生后期开展老年人群衰弱评估及相关研究提供参考。通过本综述，得出以下主要结论：衰弱的评估方法分为筛查方法和综合评估方法，建议将衰弱表型定义（FFP）、蒂尔堡衰弱指标（TFI）、格罗宁根衰弱指标（GFI）、衰弱量表（FRAIL）、衰弱综合评估工具（CFAI）、步速、握力和起立-行走试验（TUGT）作为社区门诊衰弱筛查方法，将埃德蒙顿衰弱量表（EFS）和衰弱指数（FI）用于综合评估。各评估方法在不同人群中的适用性和有效性，仍需未来进一步研究验证。

关键词: 社区, 老年人, 衰弱, 评估, 综述

DONG Bingru,GU Jie. Evaluation Methods of Frailty in the Community-dwelling Elderly　[J]. Chinese General Practice, 2021, 24(10): 1302-1308. DOI: 10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2021.00.012.
董冰茹,顾杰. 社区老年人衰弱评估方法的研究进展[J]. 中国全科医学, 2021, 24(10): 1302-1308. DOI: 10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2021.00.012.

References

［1］MARTINSON M，BERRIDGE C．Successful aging and its discontents：a systematic review of thesocial gerontology literature［J］．Gerontologist，2015，55（1）：58-69．DOI：10.1093/geront/gnu037.
［2］WU C K，SMIT E，XUE Q L，et al．Prevalence and correlates of frailty among community-dwelling Chinese older adults：the China Health and Retirement Longitudinal Study［J］．J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci，2017，73（1）：102-108．DOI：10.1093/gerona/glx098.
［3］XU W H，LI Y X，WU C K．Incidence of frailty among community-dwelling older adults：a nationally representative profile in China［J］．BMC Geriatr，2019，19（1）：378．DOI：10.1186/s12877-019-1393-7.
［4］MA L N，TANG Z，ZHANG L，et al．Prevalence of frailty and associated factors in the community-dwelling population of China［J］．J Am Geriatr Soc，2018，66（3）：559-564．DOI： 10.1111/jgs.15214.
［5］ROCKWOOD K，STADNYK K，MACKNIGHT C，et al．A brief clinical instrument to classify frailty in elderly people［J］．Lancet，1999，353（9148）：205-206．DOI：10.1016/S0140-6736(98)04402-X.
［6］WINOGRAD C H，GERETY M B，CHUNG M，et al．Screening for frailty：criteria and predictors of outcomes［J］．J Am Geriatr Soc，1991，39（8）：778-784．DOI：10.1111/j.1532-5415.1991.tb02700.x.
［7］WINOGRAD C H．Targeting strategies：an overview of criteria and outcomes［J］．J Am Geriatr Soc，1991，39（9pt2）：s25-35．DOI：10.1111/j.1532-5415.1991.tb05930.x.
［8］EELES E M，WHITE S V，O'MAHONY S M，et al．The impact of frailty and delirium on mortality in older inpatients［J］．Age Ageing，2012，41（3）：412-416．DOI：10.1093/ageing/afs021.
［9］HOOGENDIJK E O，AFILALO J，ENSRUD K E，et al．Frailty：implications for clinical practice and public health［J］．Lancet，2019，394（10206）：1365-1375．DOI：10.1016/S0140-6736(19)31786-6.
［10］于普林，王建业．加强老年人衰弱综合征的防治研究［J］．中华老年医学杂志，2015，34（12）：1281．DOI：10.3760/cma.j.issn.0254-9026.2015.12.001.
YU P L，WANG J Y．Emphasis on prevention and treatment of frailty syndrome［J］．Clin J Geriatr，2015，34（12）：1281．DOI：10.3760/cma.j.issn.0254-9026.2015.12.001.
［11］郝秋奎，李峻，董碧蓉，等．老年患者衰弱评估与干预中国专家共识［J］．中华老年医学杂志，2017，36（3）：251-256．DOI：10.3760/cma.j.issn.0254-9026.2017.03.007．
HAO Q K，LI J，DONG B R，et al．Chinese experts consensus on assessment and intervention forelderly patients with frailty［J］．Clin J Geriatr，2017，36（3）：251-256．DOI：10.3760/cma.j.issn.0254-9026.2017.03.007.
［12］FRIED L P，TANGEN C M，WALSTON J，et al．Frailty in older adults：evidence for a phenotype［J］．J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci，2001，56（3）：m146-156．DOI：10.1093/gerona/56.3.m146.
［13］MITNITSKI A B，MOGILNER A J，ROCKWOOD K．Accumulation of deficits as a proxy measure of aging［J］．Scientific World Journal，2001，1：323-336．DOI：10.1100/tsw.2001.58.
［14］GOBBENS R J，VAN ASSEN M A，LUIJKX K G，et al．The Tilburg Frailty Indicator：psychometric properties［J］．J Am Med Dir Assoc，2010，11（5）：344-355．DOI：10.1016/j.jamda.2009.11.003.
［15］DONG L J，LIU N，TIAN X，et al．Reliability and validity of the Tilburg Frailty Indicator（TFI） among Chinese community-dwelling older people［J］．Arch Gerontol Geriatr，2017，73： 21-28．DOI：10.1016/j.archger.2017.07.001.
［16］PETERS L L，BOTER H，BUSKENS E，et al．Measurement properties of the Groningen Frailty Indicator in home-dwelling and institutionalized elderly people［J］．J Am Med Dir Assoc，2012，13（6）：546-551．DOI：10.1016/j.jamda.2012.04.007.
［17］TIAN X，QIAO X，DONG L J，et al．Cross-cultural adaptation and psychometric properties of the Groningen Frailty Indicator（GFI）among Chinese community-dwelling older adults［J］．Geriatr Nurs，2020，41（3）：236-241．DOI：10.1016/j.gerinurse.2019.10.002.
［18］MORLEY J E，MALMSTROM T K，MILLER D K．A simple frailty questionnaire（FRAIL） predicts outcomes in middle aged African Americans［J］．J Nutr Health Aging，2012，16（7）：601-608．DOI：10.1007/s12603-012-0084-2.
［19］DONG L J，QIAO X，TIAN X，et al．Cross-cultural adaptation and validation of the FRAIL scale in Chinese community-dwelling older adults［J］．J Am Med Dir Assoc，2018，19（1）：12-17．DOI：10.1016/j.jamda.2017.06.011.
［20］DE WITTE N，GOBBENS R，DE DONDER L，et al．The comprehensive frailty assessment instrument：development，validity and reliability［J］．Geriatr Nurs，2013，34（4）：274-281．DOI：10.1016/j.gerinurse.2013.03.002.
［21］QIAO X，WANG C，TIAN X，et al．Cross-cultural adaptation and validation of the comprehensive frailty assessment instrument in Chinese community-dwelling older adults［J］．Geriatr Gerontol Int，2018，18（2）：301-307．DOI：10.1111/ggi.13183.
［22］PODSIADLO D，RICHARDSON S．The timed "Up & Go"：a test of basic functional mobility for frail elderly persons［J］．J Am Geriatr Soc，1991，39（2）：142-148．DOI：10.1111/j.1532-5415.1991.tb01616.x.
［23］WOO J．Walking speed：a summary indicator of frailty?［J］．J Am Med Dir Assoc，2015，16（8）：635-637．DOI：10.1016/j.jamda.2015.04.003.
［24］CRUZ-JENTOFT A J，BAEYENS J P，BAUER J M，et al．Sarcopenia：European consensus on definition and diagnosis：report of the European working group on sarcopenia in older People［J］．Age Ageing，2010，39（4）：412-423．DOI：10.1093/ageing/afq034.
［25］ROLFSON D B，MAJUMDAR S R，TSUYUKI R T，et al．Validity and reliability of the Edmonton Frail Scale［J］．Age Ageing，2006，35（5）：526-529．DOI：10.1093/ageing/afl041.
［26］杨柳，鲍立华，周全，等．中文版Edmonton虚弱评估量表的信效度研究［J］．国际老年医学杂志，2016，37（3）：135-137．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1674-7593.2016.03.012.
［27］DENT E，LIEN C，LIM W S，et al．The asia-pacific clinical practice guidelines for the management of frailty［J］．J Am Med Dir Assoc，2017，18（7）：564-575．DOI：10.1016/j.jamda.2017.04.018.
［28］CHEN C Y，WU S C，CHEN L J，et al．The prevalence of subjective frailty and factors associated with frailty in Taiwan［J］．Arch Gerontol Geriatr，2010，50（s1）：s43-47．DOI：10.1016/S0167-4943(10)70012-1.
［29］ROCKWOOD K，MITNITSKI A．Frailty in relation to the accumulation of deficits［J］．J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci，2007，62（7）：722-727．DOI：10.1093/gerona/62.7.722.
［30］MITNITSKI A，SONG X，SKOOG I，et al．Relative fitness and frailty of elderly men and women in developed countries and their relationship with mortality［J］．J Am Geriatr Soc，2005，53（12）：2184-2189．DOI：10.1111/j.1532-5415.2005.00506.x.
［31］DAVIS D H，ROCKWOOD M R，MITNITSKI A B，et al．Impairments in mobility and balance in relation to frailty［J］．Arch Gerontol Geriatr，2011，53（1）：79-83．DOI： 10.1016/j.archger.2010.06.013.
［32］SEARLE S D，MITNITSKI A，GAHBAUER E A，et al．A standard procedure for creating a frailty index［J］．BMC Geriatr，2008，8：24．DOI：10.1186/1471-2318-8-24.
［33］WOO J，ZHENG Z，LEUNG J，et al．Prevalence of frailty and contributory factors in three Chinese populations with different socioeconomic and healthcare characteristics［J］．BMC Geriatr，2015，15：163．DOI：10.1186/s12877-015-0160-7.
［34］FANG X，SHI J，SONG X，et al．Frailty in relation to the risk of falls，fractures，and mortality in older Chinese adults：results from the Beijing Longitudinal Study of Aging［J］．J Nutr Health Aging，2012，16（10）：903-907．DOI：10.1007/s12603-012-0368-6.
［35］WANG C，JI X，WU X，et al．Frailty in relation to the risk of alzheimer's disease，dementia，and death in older chinese adults：a seven-year prospective study［J］．J Nutr Health Aging，2017，21（6）：648-654．DOI：10.1007/s12603-016-0798-7.
［36］ZHU Y S，LIU Z Y，WANG Y，et al．Agreement between the frailty index and phenotype and their associations with falls and overnight hospitalizations［J］．Arch Gerontol Geriatr，2016，66：161-165．DOI：10.1016/j.archger.2016.06.004.
［37］LIU Z，WANG Q，ZHI T，et al．Frailty index and its relation to falls and overnight hospitalizations in elderly Chinese people：a population-based study［J］．J Nutr Health Aging，2016，20（5）：561-568．DOI：10.1007/s12603-015-0625-6.
［38］YANG F，GU D．Predictability of frailty index and its components on mortality in older adults in China［J］．BMC Geriatr，2016，16：145．DOI：10.1186/s12877-016-0317-z.
［39］DUPRE M E，GU D，WARNER D F，et al．Frailty and type of death among older adults in China：prospective cohort study［J］．BMJ，2009，338：b1175．DOI：10.1136/bmj.b1175.
［40］SEPEHRI K，BRALEY M S，CHINDA B，et al．A computerized frailty assessment tool at points-of-care：development of a standalone electronic comprehensive geriatric assessment/frailty index（eFI-CGA）［J］．Front Public Health，2020，8：89．DOI：10.3389/fpubh.2020.00089.
［41］李菲，刘慧松，查龙肖，等．中文版老年人衰弱评估量表的修订和信效度评价［J］．护理学杂志，2017，32（7）：18-20，27．DOI：10.3870/j.issn.1001-4152.2017.07.018.
LI F，LIU H S，ZHA L X，et al．Reliability and validity testing of the Chinese version of Tilburg Frailty Indicator［J］．Journal of Nursing Science，2017，32（7）：18-20，27．DOI：10.3870/j.issn.1001-4152.2017.07.018.

［42］奚兴，郭桂芳，孙静．中文版Tilburg衰弱评估量表的信效度研究［J］．护理学报，2013，20（16）：1-5．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1008-9969.2013.16.001.

［43］METZELTHIN S F，DANIELS R，VAN ROSSUM E，et al．The psychometric properties of three self-report screening instruments for identifying frail older people in the community［J］．BMC Public Health，2010，10：176．DOI：10.1186/1471-2458-10-176.

［44］SCHUURMANS H，STEVERINK N，LINDENBERG S，et al．Old or frail：what tells us more?［J］．J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci，2004，59（9）：M962-965．DOI：10.1093/gerona/59.9.m962.

［45］相玮. 格列宁根衰弱指标量表的信效度分析及应用［D］．长春：吉林大学，2019.

［46］LOPEZ D，FLICKER L，DOBSON A.Validation of the frail scale in a cohort of older Australian women［J］．J Am Geriatr Soc，2012，60（1）：171-173．DOI：10.1111/j.1532-5415.2011.03746.x.

［47］LAM F M H，LEUNG J C S，KWOK T C Y.The Clinical Potential of Frailty Indicators on Identifying Recurrent Fallers in the Community：The Mr.Os and Ms.OS Cohort Study in Hong Kong［J］．J Am Med Dir Assoc，2019，20（12）：1605-1610．DOI：10.1016/j.jamda.2019.06.019.

［48］WOO J，YU R，WONG M，et al．Frailty Screening in the Community Using the FRAIL Scale［J］．J Am Med Dir Assoc，2015，16（5）：412-419．DOI：10.1016/j.jamda.2015.01.087.

［49］WOO J，LEUNG J，MORLEY J E.Comparison of frailty indicators based on clinical phenotype and the multiple deficit approach in predicting mortality and physical limitation［J］．J Am Geriatr Soc，2012，60（8）：1478-1486．DOI：10.1111/j.1532-5415.2012.04074.x.

［50］王坤，陈长香，李淑杏. 衰弱综合评估工具的汉化及信效度检验［J］．中国康复理论与实践，2017，23（01）：72-76．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1006-9771.2017.01.017.

WANG K，CHEN C X，LI S X.Reliability and validity of Chinese version of comprehensive frailty assessment instrument［J］．Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Theory and Practice，2017，23（1）：72-76．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1006-9771.2017.01.017.

［51］VICCARO L J，PERERA S，STUDENSKI S A.Is timed up and go better than gait speed in predicting health，function，and falls in older adults?［J］．J Am Geriatr Soc，2011，59（5）：887-892．DOI： 10.1111/j.1532-5415.2011.03336.x.

［52］HUANG W N W，PERERA S，VANSWEARINGEN J，et al．Performance measures predict onset of activity of daily living difficulty in community-dwelling older adults［J］．J Am Geriatr Soc，2010，58（5）：844-852．DOI：10.1111/j.1532-5415.2010.02820.x.

［53］KANG L，HAN P，WANG J，et al．Timed Up and Go Test can predict recurrent falls：a longitudinal study of the communitydwelling elderly in China［J］．Clin Interv Aging，2017，12：2009-2016．DOI：10.2147/cia.S138287.

［54］STUDENSKI S，PERERA S，PATEL K，et al．Gait speed and survival in older adults［J］．JAMA，2011，305（1）：50-58．DOI：10.1001/jama.2010.1923.

［55］ODDEN M C，PERALTA C A，HAAN M N，et al．Rethinking the association of high blood pressure with mortality in elderly adults：the impact of frailty［J］．Arch Intern Med，2012，172（15）：1162-1168．DOI：10.1001/archinternmed.2012.2555.

［56］CASTELL M V，SÁNCHEZ M，JULIÁN R，et al．Frailty prevalence and slow walking speed in persons age 65 and older：implications for primary care［J］．BMC Fam Pract，2013，14（86）．DOI：10.1186/1471-2296-14-86.

［57］GIAMPAOLI S，FERRUCCI L，CECCHI F，et al．Handgrip strength predicts incident disability in non-disabled older men［J］．Age Ageing，1999，28（3）：283-288．DOI：10.1093/ageing/28.3.283.

［58］RANTANEN T，GURALNIK J M，FOLEY D，et al．Midlife hand grip strength as a predictor of old age disability［J］．JAMA，1999，281（6）：558-560．DOI：10.1001/jama.281.6.558.

［59］LEE L，PATEL T，COSTA A，et al．Screening for frailty in primary care：Accuracy of gait speed and hand-grip strength［J］．Can Fam Physician，2017，63（1）：e51-e57.

［60］CLEGG A，ROGERS L，YOUNG J.Diagnostic test accuracy of simple instruments for identifying frailty in community-dwelling older people：a systematic review［J］．Age Ageing，2015，44（1）：148-152．DOI：10.1093/ageing/afu157.

［61］AUYEUNG T W，LEE J S，LEUNG J，et al．The selection of a screening test for frailty identification in community-dwelling older adults［J］．J Nutr Health Aging，2014，18（2）：199-203．DOI： 10.1007/s12603-013-0365-4.

［62］SMITH J L，LINDLEY R I.The assessment of frailty in older people in acute care［J］．Australas J Ageing，2009，28（4）：170．DOI：10.1111/j.1741-6612.2009.00405.x.

［63］ROLFSON D B，WILCOCK G，MITNITSKI A，et al．An assessment of neurocognitive speed in relation to frailty［J］．Age Ageing，2013，42（2）：191-196．DOI：10.1093/ageing/afs185.

［64］YANG L，JIANG Y，XU S，et al．Evaluation of frailty status among older people living in urban communities by Edmonton Frail Scale in Wuhu，China：a cross-sectional study［J］．Contemp Nurse，2018，54（6）：630-639．DOI：10.1080/10376178.2018.1552525.

［65］GARCIA F J，GUTIERREZ A，ALFARO A，et al．The prevalence of frailty syndrome in an older population from Spain. The Toledo Study for Healthy Aging［J］．J Nutr Health Aging，2011，15（10）：852-856．DOI：10.1007/s12603-011-0075-8.

［66］DE LEPELEIRE J，ILIFFE S，MANN E，et al．Frailty：an emerging concept for general practice［J］．Br J Gen Pract，2009，59（562）：e177-182．DOI：10.3399/bjgp09X420653.

[1]	YAO Yuzhong, MA Xiaojun, SONG Huan, ZHONG Yu. The Management Effect of Diabetes "1358 model" on Community Diabetes Patients Based on "Precision Management Combining General Care and Specialty Care" [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(34): 4308-4314.
[2]	QIN Fengyin, ZHANG Qishan, LAI Jinjia, HUANG Yimin, HAN Guoyin, SUN Xinglan, WANG Fen, TAN Yibing. Current Status and Influencing Factors of the Intention to Screen for High-risk Stroke among Community Residents in Guangdong [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(34): 4283-4289.
[3]	FENG Xiaoyu, LI Wanling, LYU Siman, NI Cuiping, WANG Haocheng, LIU Yu. International Research Status and Hot Spot Analysis of InterRAI HC Based on Bibliometrics [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(34): 4351-4358.
[4]	GU Hanxin, LIU Yang, LIU Yuanli. Falls Prevention Intervention for Community-dwelling Older Adults from the Perspective of Policy Tools: an International Comparative Study [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(34): 4231-4238.
[5]	ZHOU Jie, HU Lingjuan, HUAI Qingyu. Evaluation of Medical Level in China by Provinces Based on Principal Component Analysis and TOPSIS Model [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(34): 4254-4260.
[6]	LI Dianjiang, PAN Enchun, SUN Zhongming, WEN Jinbo, WANG Miaomiao, WU Ming, SHEN Chong. The Current Status and Influencing Factors of Clinical Inertia in Type 2 Diabetes Patients in Community [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(34): 4296-4301.
[7]	HUANG Jinling, ZENG Zhirong. The Logic and Trend of Urban Community Health Service Policies in China [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(34): 4239-4245.
[8]	YANG Hui, HU Ruwei, LIU Ruqing, LU Junfeng, WU Jinglan. Relationship between Community Health Service Experience and Glycemic Control Outcomes in Patients with Diabetes Mellitus [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(34): 4290-4295.
[9]	WANG Yue, CHEN Qing, LIU Lurong. Detection Rate of Depression and Its Influencing Factors in Chinese Elderly: a Meta-analysis [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(34): 4329-4335.
[10]	XU Jian, DAI Fangfang, PAN Wenlei, HUANG Qian, LU Ping, WANG Jianfeng, JIA Huan, YANG Yuqi, HUANG Jiaoling. Visual Analysis of Hotspots and Cutting-edge Trends of Community TCM Service Research in China in the Context of Healthy China [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(34): 4343-4350.
[11]	WANG Jie, LI Shiming, WEI Shifei, WANG Ningli. Importance of the Role of Primary Care in Myopia Prevention and Control Behavioral Intervention among Children [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(33): 4213-4217.
[12]	YU Xinyan, ZHAO Jun, ZHAO Xiaoye, JIANG Qingru, CHEN Yatian, WANG Yan, ZHANG Haicheng. Application of Mobile Smart Healthcare in the Prevention and Control of Cardiovascular Diseases in Elderly Patients with Chronic Diseases in Primary Care [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(33): 4167-4172.
[13]	ZHANG Siyu, ZHOU Yuqiu, DU Xiaohui, WANG Zhengjun. Advances in Duration of Untreated Psychosis and Its Early Intervention [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(33): 4110-4117.
[14]	WANG Xu, WEI Xu, ZHU Liguo, FENG Tianxiao, WANG Zhipeng, SHI Bin. Research Ideas of the Efficacy Mechanism and Prospect Analysis of Traditional Chinese Manipulative Therapy on Treating Spinal Degenerative Diseases with Combination of Medicine and Industry [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(33): 4118-4124.
[15]	XIN Gongkai, CONG Xin, YUAN Lei, CHENG Yuetong, NI Cuiping, ZHANG Weiwei, ZHANG Pingping, LIU Yu. Research Progress on Comprehensive Assessment Tools for the Elderly with Dementia [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(33): 4103-4109.