农村订单定向医学毕业生在乡镇卫生院工作现状、长期工作意愿及其影响因素的质性研究

doi:10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2021.00.280

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 背景　2010年我国农村订单定向医学生免费培养工作启动，旨在为农村地区培养具备本科学历的全科医生，改善农村地区基层医师匮乏的状况。2018年首批农村订单定向医学生返回乡镇卫生院工作，开始履行为期3年的农村地区卫生服务合约。目的　了解农村订单定向医学生在乡镇卫生院的工作现状，以及服务期满后继续留在农村乡镇卫生院工作的意愿及影响因素，探索促进农村地区长期保留医疗卫生人才的机制。方法　于2019年1—8月，对64例广西医科大学2015届农村订单定向医学毕业生进行半结构式焦点小组访谈，访谈内容包括在农村乡镇卫生院的薪酬待遇、工作内容、工作氛围、工作条件、服务期满后继续留在乡镇卫生院工作的意愿及影响因素等。将访谈录音资料完整转录为书面文字，采用主题分析法编码、提炼主题。结果　访谈共提取11个主题，分别为：农村订单定向医学毕业生在乡镇卫生院的薪酬水平达到预期，但呈现地域差异化；兑现入编、“五险一金”等待遇，基本解决住房问题；进修培训机会少；职务晋升空间大；工作内容以临床诊疗活动为主，部分涉及医技工作；工作氛围和谐，竞争感不强，院负责人重视；基本药物不足，所学难以致用；实验室检查设备落后，卫技人员匮乏，无法开展多种常用检查；服务期满后继续留在乡镇卫生院工作的意愿不明确；支持乡镇发展的国家政策、明晰的职业发展、友好的工作氛围、解决农村卫生问题的意愿、在农村地区工作获得的成就感等是促进其长期留任乡镇卫生院的因素；基本药物短缺、医疗设备落后、培训进修机会缺乏、工作繁重及收入水平偏低等是阻碍其长期留任乡镇卫生院的因素。结论　多数农村订单定向医学毕业生暂未明确长期在农村乡镇卫生院工作的意愿，薪酬水平不是影响其服务期满后继续留在农村地区工作的主要因素，而乡镇卫生院基本药物不足、医疗设备落后及继续教育短缺是阻碍其长期留在农村地区工作的主要因素。

关键词: 全科医生；农村订单定向医学生；教育, 医学；工作现状；长期工作意愿；影响因素分析；质性研究

Abstract: Background　The rural-oriented tuition-free medical education（RTME）program has been launched in China since 2010，aiming to provide rural areas with general practitioners with medical undergraduate degrees and to address the shortage of rural physicians. The first graduates with RTME came back to the contracted township health center to work in 2018 and started fulfilling a 3-year obliged health services in rural areas. Objective　To investigate the working status of graduates with RTME in rural primary health care institutions，their intentions towards long-term retention in rural areas and relevant associated factors. Methods　A qualitative study was conducted from January to August 2019，using a semi-structured focus group discussion with 64 individuals with RTME who graduated from Guangxi Medical University in 2015 and started serving local rural areas in 2018. Guided by an outline，the discussion covered issues about salary，scope of work，work atmosphere，and working conditions in township health centers，intention of retaining in the township health center after fulfilling the contractual obligations，and factors associated with long-term retention in township health centers，and was recorded，transcribed，and organized into themes using thematic analysis. Results　A total of 11 main themes emerged，including：salaries in the township health center met expectations of most graduates with RTME but showed geographical differences；the township health center has kept its promise of providing officially budgeted posts and purchasing the "five social insurances and one housing fund" as well as basically solving the housing problem；the opportunities for continuing medical education were reported to be insufficient；graduates with RTME would be easily considered for administrative posts of rural primary health care organizations；graduates with RTME mainly engaged in clinical diagnosis and treatment of disease，some of them also in auxiliary examinations；graduates with RTME worked in an atmosphere of harmony and less competition，and would be noticed significantly by the leaders；insufficient essential drugs crippled performances of graduates with RTME；both behindhand medical equipment and deficiency of health technicians made some common auxiliary examinations unavailable in township health centers；the attitudes towards retention in township health centers after fulfilling the contractual obligations were unclear；national policies in favor of towns and villages development，promising career development，friendly work atmosphere，willingness to address rural health issues，and sense of achievement derived from working in rural areas were factors encouraging long-term retention in township health centers；insufficient essential drugs，behindhand medical equipment，scarce opportunities for continuing medical education，heavy workload，and low salaries were factors impairing long-term retention in township health centers. Conclusion　The graduates with RTME showed unclear intentions towards long-term retention in township health centers. The salary was not a leading factor to impair their retention in such organizations after fulfilling the contractual obligations. However，insufficient essential drugs，behindhand medical equipment，and scare opportunities for continuing medical education emerged as major barriers for rural areas to retain these graduates.

Key words: General practitioners；Target admission medical graduates；Education, medicine；Job status；Will of long term retention；Root causes analysis；Qualitative study

申颖,黄星,于佳,等. 农村订单定向医学毕业生在乡镇卫生院工作现状、长期工作意愿及其影响因素的质性研究[J]. 中国全科医学, 2021, 24(31): 3995-4002. DOI: 10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2021.00.280.
SHEN Ying,HUANG Xing,YU Jia, et al. Working Status，Willingness of Long-term Retention in Township Heath Centers and Associated Factors in Targeted Admission Medical Graduates：a Qualitative Study　[J]. Chinese General Practice, 2021, 24(31): 3995-4002. DOI: 10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2021.00.280.

参考文献

［1］国家发展改革委，卫生部，教育部，等. 关于印发开展农村订单定向医学生免费培养工作实施意见的通知［EB/OL］. （2010-06-02）［2021-01-19］. http://www.moe.gov.cn/jyb_xxgk/moe_1777/moe_1779/201012/t20101216_112693.html.
［2］黄星，左延莉，唐琦，等. 广西农村订单定向免费医学生培养项目实施效果调查分析［J］. 中国卫生事业管理，2019，36（3）：204-207. DOI：CNKI:SUN:ZWSG.0.2019-03-017.
［3］李玉华，郝婷，陈立章. 我国高校农村订单定向医学本科生培养方案现状研究［J］. 中国全科医学，2018，21（16）：1989-1992，1997. DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1007-9572.2018.16.017.
LI Y H，HAO T，CHEN L Z. Medical science undergraduate free training programs specifically designed for rural practice in China［J］. Chinese General Practice，2018，21（16）：1989-1992，1997. DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1007-9572.2018.16.017.
［4］仇蕾洁，张雪文，马桂峰，等. 基于供给侧视角的基层医疗机构卫生人力资源短缺问题研究［J］. 中国卫生事业管理，2018，35（11）：804-808，838. DOI：CNKI:SUN:ZWSG.0.2018-11-003.
［5］张兰，张青，于梦，等. 培养基层卫生人才能力提升的探索与实践［J］. 继续医学教育，2020，34（6）：4-6.
［6］李娇娇，孔凡磊，聂婉颖，等. 我国基层卫生人才队伍建设现状与思考［J］. 中国农村卫生事业管理，2020，40（12）：864-868.
［7］左延莉，李虹，韦思羽，等. 广西全科医生的数量和分布情况及需要量预测研究［J］. 中国全科医学，2016，19（19）：2252-2257. DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1007-9572.2016.19.005.
ZUO Y L，LI H，WEI S Y，et al. Number and distribution of general practitioners and prediction of demand for general practitioners in Guangxi［J］. Chinese General Practice，2016，19（19）：2252-2257. DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1007-9572.2016.19.005.
［8］胡丹，陈楚康，张超，等. 我国农村订单定向免费医学生培养成效及存在问题［J］. 中国卫生政策研究，2018，11（9）：28-33. DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1674-2982.2018.09.005.
HU D，CHEN C K，ZHANG C，et al. Effectiveness and challenges of targeted admission medical education program in rural China［J］. China Journal of Health Policy，2018，11（9）：28-33. DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1674-2982.2018.09.005.
［9］蔡莹，刘北忠，周勇，等. 对重庆市农村订单定向免费医学生培养的访谈及分析［J］. 中华医学教育探索杂志，2018，17（7）：753-756. DOI：10.3760/cma.j.issn.2095-1485.2018.07.023.
［10］O'BRIEN B C，HARRIS I B，BECKMAN T J，et al. Standards for reporting qualitative research：a synthesis of recommendations［J］. Acad Med，2014，89（9）：1245-1251. DOI：10.1097/ACM.0000000000000388.
［11］MICHELLE E，VARPIO K L. Thematic analysis of qualitative data：AMEE Guide No.131［J］. Medi Teach，2020，42（8）：846-854. DOI：10.1080/0142159X.2020.1755030.
［12］XU W，ZAMMIT K. Applying thematic analysis to education：a hybrid approach to interpreting data in practitioner research［J］. Int J Qual Meth，2020，19：1-9. DOI：10.1171/1609406920918810.
［13］国务院. 国务院关于建立全科医生制度的指导意见［EB/OL］. （2010-06-02）［2021-01-19］. http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/content/2011-07/06/content_6123.htm.
［14］教育部，国家发展改革委，国家卫生计生委，等. 关于进一步做好农村订单定向医学生免费培养工作的意见［EB/OL］. （2015-05-19）［2021-01-19］. http://old.moe.gov.cn/publicfiles/business/htmlfiles/moe/s7955/201505/188004.html.
［15］国务院办公厅. 国务院办公厅关于改革完善全科医生培养与使用激励机制的意见［EB/OL］. （2018-01-24）［2021-01-19］. http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/content/2018-01/24/content_5260073.htm.
［16］王子岳，胡丹，张柏松，等. 订单定向医学生的工作意愿：基于四所医学院校的三年跟踪分析［J］. 中国卫生政策研究，2020，13（11）：57-62. DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1674-2982.2020.11.009.
WANG Z Y，HU D，ZHANG B S，et al. Analysis on the targeted admission medical graduates and their work preference in rural areas：a three-year survey conducted in four medical schools［J］. China Journal of Health Policy，2020，13（11）：57-62. DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1674-2982.2020.11.009.
［17］宋娟，梅珊珊. 陕西省某医学院校农村订单定向医学本科毕业生履约情况研究［J］. 陕西教育（高教），2018，12（1）：59-60. DOI：10.16773/j.cnki.1002-2058.2018.01.034.
［18］MARCHAND C，PECKHAM S. Address the crisis of GP recruitment and retention：a systematic review［J］. Brit J Gen Pract，2017，67（657）：e227-237. DOI：10.3399/bjgp17X689929.
［19］CHAN B T B，DEGANI N，CRICHTON T，et al. Factors influencing family physicians to enter rural practice：does rural or urban background make a difference?［J］. Can Fam Physician，2005，51：1246-1247.
［20］FLORES E L L，MANAHAN E M R，LACANILAO M P B，et al. Factors affecting retention in the doctors to the Barrios Program（Philippines） from 2012 to 2019：a mixed methods study［J］. Res Sq，2021，1：1-18. DOI：10.21203/rs.3.rs-152526/v2.
［21］BUDHATHOKI S S，ZWANIKKEN P A C，POKHAREL P K，et al. Factors influencing medical students' motivation to practice in rural areas in low-income and middle-income countries：a systematic review［J］. BMJ Open，2017，7：e013501-013509. DOI：10.1136/bmjopen-2016-013501.
［22］MOHAMMADIAGHDAM N，DOSHMANGIR L，BABAIE J，et al. Determining factors in the retention of physicians in rural and underdeveloped areas：a systematic review［J］. BMC Fam Pract，2020，21：216-238.
［23］MATSUMOTO M，OKAYAMA M，INOUE K，et al. Factors associated with rural doctors' intention to continue a rural career：a survey of 3 072 doctors in Japan［J］. J Rural Health，2005，13：219-225.
［24］SAPUTRI T O，NOORKHAKIM A，TANGKERE H，et al. Analysis of job satisfaction and factors affecting dentists' retention in rural and remote areas of Indonesia［J］. Sci Dent J，2021，2：26-32.
［25］周晓峰，陈莉，汪俊华，等. 贵州省农村订单定向全科医学生基层就业意向的研究［J］. 中国卫生事业管理，2018，35（1）：56-59，76. DOI：CNKI:SUN:ZWSG.0.2018-01-019.
ZHOU X F，CHEN L，WANG J H，et al. Study on the employment intentions of the runal orders targeted genera practice stdents in grassroots units in Guizhou Province［J］. Chinese Health Service Management，2018，35（1）：56-59，76. DOI：CNKI:SUN:ZWSG.0.2018-01-019.
［26］FANG P Q，LIU X L，HUANG L，et al. Factors that influence the turnover intention of Chinese village doctors based on the investigation results of Xiangyang City in Hubei Province［J］. Int J Equity Health，2014，13：84-92.
［27］ROGERS M E，SEARLE J，CREED P A. Why do junior doctors not want to work in a rural location，and what would induce them to do so?［J］. Aust J Rural Health，2010，18（5）：181-186.
［28］BORRACCI R A，ARRIBALZAGA E B，COUTO J L，et al. Factors affecting willingness to practice medicine in underserved areas：a survey of Argentine medical students［J］. Rural Remote Health，2015，15（4）：3485-3493.
［29］SNOW R C，ASABIR K，MUTUMBA M，et al. Key factors leading to reduced recruitment and retention of health professionals in remote areas of Ghana：a qualitative study and proposed policy solutions［J］. Hum Resour Health，2011，9：13-22.
［30］VISCOMI M，LARKINS S，GUPTA T S. Recruitment and retention of general practitioners in rural Canada and Australia：a review of the literature［J］. Can J Rural Med，2013，18（1）：13-23.
［31］WENGHOFER E F，HOGENBIRK J C，TIMONY P E. Impact of the rural pipeline in medical education：practice locations of recently graduated family physicians in Ontario［J］. Hum Resour Health，2017，15（1）：16-21. DOI：10.1186/s12960-017-0191-6.
［32］MYHRE D L，BAJAJ S，WOLOSCHUK W. Practice locations of longitudinal integrated clerkship graduates：a matched-cohort study［J］. Can J Rural Med，2016，21（1）：13-16.